Katana vs european armor

Katana vs european armor


May 06, 2018 · I’m going to use an 13th century KNIGHT TEMPLAR vs an 13th century SAMURAI. But if compare army of samurai from whole Japan vs army of knight from any nation in Europe. Medieval Armor. As my sources clearly demonstrate, the Samurai did indeed wear heavier armor. If the katana is better in cutting the Japanese will give it supernatural cutting prowess. I have seen some videos supporting this but of course, I have bias as well as a proud European. But I think 1 on 1 knight would win . Medieval Weaponry - Warfare, Arms, Armour, Defenses, open battles and castle Unlike the bow or spear, the sword is a purely military weapon, and this has The crossbow prod is very short compared to ordinary bows, resulting in a short  Samurai Facts Vs Samurai Myths And Legends 2. But Katanas Are Just Better because Tommy can run with them and still kill in one hit. While there are early predecessors such as the Roman-era lorica segmentata, full plate armour developed in Europe during the Late Middle Ages, especially in the context of the Hundred Years' War, from the coat of plates worn over mail Jul 17, 2018 · But we do have record of some katana such as the Honjo Masamune that cleaved a steel helmet another samurai was wearing and the sword was not damaged. Oct 09, 2019 · That evolution is one of the themes of Samurai: The Beauty and Pedigree of Warriors, an exhibition currently being held by the Fukuoka City Museum. had a better structure, Negatory. Knight Templar Has: extreme training skills chain-mail A Crossbow A Pole-arm A bastard sword a morning star a kite shield and a dagger VS Samurai Has: Katana Naginata Spik Well this does not answer a few simple questions. Jul 08, 2011 · Katana can penetrate plate armor. Apr 28, 2013 · The katana is a sword that reflects Japan and its people, therefore the Japanese will have favor to their own sword. Gungnir actually inverts this. . 20 Jan 2017 How would a Katana fare against high-medieval era armor, from the most . Second the broad sword is for hacking while the katana was for a swift cut. I cannot speak for European styles as my knowledge is limited but SweetDaddySiki can answer your questions. Read about both swords and learn which we think is better. Now I would say the same about any European longsword or hand and a half sword too. However, while the European Longsword may be a better weapon for extended combat on the battlefield, it is important to remember that the Katana was as much a work of art as a weapon, and was a source of pride and identity for the Samurai. Long Battle Axe vs Katana vs Longsword Viking 2 handed Long Battle Axe vs Samurai Katana vs European Knight Longsword Slashing armor does not work very well though and that's where the Katana vs. The Katana blade was often passed down through generations of samurai in a family. Feb 21, 2013 · The Katana could certainly pierce plate armour/ mail if used in a stabbing fashion rather than slashing. Longsword and Katana Considered. Feb 21, 2013 · So I've always wondered, how would a Katana stand up to European style plate armor or mail? Could the Katana cut through said armors, or not? I'm thinking it would be pretty useless, but a lot of my well. This question of which is better: the European Longsword or the Katana has been around for as long as sword enthusiasts have known about both swords. The crossguard and pommel are both weapons and defensive attributes, the tsuba can sort of provide a defensive benefit but it is just not on the same level as a crossguard. (That does however kind of ignore a few things) * The people who used ginunting where in many cases Katanas are much like sabers in that they are meant as a slashing weapon where strikes using the blade's edge are emphasized. Weapons are inherently developed for the type of fighting they are to be used in and the type of enemy they are to face. Think about how many fictional shows and myths have the katana being such a cutter that armor and weapons are cut through it. Much more than the longsword. 147 pieces of samurai armor and weaponry are on display, with more than half officially designated as national treasures due to their historical significance. But its harder edge would chip easier than most other swords. As well, Deadliest Warrior tested a 3-body* Katana against 5th century Viking mail, to which the flesh-slicing blade did nothing. Because the katana's pretty much ineffective against steel plate armor, while the broadsword won't have any problems dealing with the Samurai's laquered armor. Katana Vs Medium/heavy armour = potential catestrophic damage to blade, as does any even glancing blow to solid object etc. Even if we were to assume that the katana is of modern quality, Wolfius put it quite nicely. As far as platewell, see that video of a European bastard sword being used against plate armor of unknown (probably bad) quality without backing. Arms, armor and clothing from the European continent; from Roman to European/Western Armor Synthetic Sparring Longsword - White Blade w/ Black Hilt. This is where the sword became the main and coveted weapon of the samurai. and weight to the katana were virtually useless against European plate armour and chainmail. 5:08 to see the final test of Katana VS European style armor, leather first, then a metal cuirass. Jun 29, 2016 · The classic question, knight versus samurai, who would win in a fight? Try thrusting with a Katana and you’ll figure out it really isn’t good at that (you can thrust but it’s just not as intuitive) This is good against opponents with little to no armor, but try facing a fully armored opponent (in either European knight armor or even Japanese Samurai armor). But unlike the European sword it wasn't a tool, "true" katanas were part of the Samurai, and were almost revered. samurai katana tachi broad long sword tameshigiri war warrior knight load swordsmanship bushido bushi sword smith master weap free MP4 video / 365 Loops Mar 19, 2015 · Finally the use of the sword, a katana isn't meant for prolonged use against armored opponents, you find someone lightly armored and you make your move. Knight uses a Longsword and a crossbow, no shield. In the whole "European Knight vs Samurai" hypothetical, the Knight generally kicks the piss out of the Samurai. 19 Feb 2015 I definitely believe Katanas weren't designed to fight plate armor and European armor and often was made out of inferior metal compared to  2 May 2016 I'm sorry you think that an article called “5 Reasons Why Katanas are Just when the Japanese were on the verge of getting their hands on all the European iron they could eat, the blade that can chop a tank in two, or cut through plate armor. Your source gives an exagerated number for the weight of European armor, and as such I would question its validity. A highly trained swordsman wielding a straight sword could masterfully combat this form of armor by strategically attacking the chinks visible in the pattern. You will also not have to go searching for the best prices on Paul Chen Hanwei swords, because you have already found them. European longsword debate. They were one of the best heavy cavalry in the world in that time. European swords were made first to hack. But NO sword cuts european armor – you have to penetrate with a small  31 Jul 2012 Could we implement two-handed katanas? is a video that tests a katana and a european long sword against various objects and armor. A sword is a bladed, melee weapon intended for slashing or thrusting that is longer than a knife Non-European weapons called "sword" include single- edged weapons such as the Middle Eastern scimitar, . The katana is a quick slashing weapon and is horrible for cutting through European armor. with European Longsword vs Peak Yeah, on the note of katana vs European swords. Sep 03, 2015 · If you like real history and medieval weapons and armour, and cutting tests please watch this video, you won't regret it. Said strain of fanboyism also insists that a katana versus a  17 Feb 2014 Japan's first Armored Battle is about to find out. The katana turns out to be the better can opener. katana From the medieval epics of Akira Kurosawa to the space operas of George Lucas ,  Home > Ninja Swords versus katana . Japanese Swords & Armor. If a katana got bent it wound stay bent. Apr 14, 2008 · European plate armor is roughly 100% immune, when not struck at a joint, to slashing attacks. They slice differently. the test was HEAVILY biased against the armour) and the best he could do was "world record" 13 cm cut that was so Boards > Community Central > The Vault > Outpost > Japanese katana vs EU A well crafted Japanese sword was known to be able to cut through plate armor which is not what any european blades Jun 18, 2004 · I've done some mixed-style swordfights, including European longsword versus single or twin katanas, and personally I'd say that, if we're talking about European longsword versus Samurai-style katana (obviously there are lots of other styles in either culture), the European-style swordsman would have the advantage. Apr 06, 2018 · European Knight Vs. Differences between a $200 and a $5000 Katana? What is the difference between and economical entry level katana and a sensai grade sword? This is a great question without a simple answer but if their was one, it would be easiest to say “you get what you pay for”. Japanese Samurai Medieval Europe shared many similarities with medieval Japan, however they also shared many differences. Exactly. However, Western swords of the time were typically crappy, nowhere close to the quality of medieval European weapons, and katana was oftentimes better than the Colt revolver of the In the whole "European Knight vs Samurai" hypothetical, the Knight generally kicks the piss out of the Samurai. Otaku friends seem to disagree. Bring a broadsword to asia and palace guards would literally run circles around you. e. If both swords were correlated with each other, the rapier vs katana would definitely have their own advantages in battle: in a duel, the rapier would most likely win due to it being a nimble and quick weapon that offered excellent reach despite being a single-handed weapon. Unlike the often larger European styled swords the Japanese katana is recognized by the single edged, curved blade. clashes against any other kind of sword or plate armor. While a fully-armored European warrior was entirely encased in an amazingly-articulated suit of iron, a fully armored Japanese warrior still had a lot of open weak points. Feudal Japanese Without the necessary weapons designed intentionally to face and defeat plate armor, any fighter armed with a sword alone would have difficulty (katana or not). I really have no idea how one would beat the other one using swords and bows but somebody would Jan 17, 2018 · A guy in European armor could not move like a Samurai (it's a very fluid movement with lots of flexibiity). Mar 06, 2017 · Japanese Katana VS European Longsword Samurai sword VS Knight Broadsword Answer Video Bow Vs Padded Armor and Leather Armor Reply to The Game Theorists Matpat - Duration: 10:19. It was about the purpose and weight for protection. The katana was crafted for use against flesh and wooden/leather armor. You're not slashing through chain mail with any sword. Against enemies with these armor variants, a mace of equal quality is usually  16 Apr 2015 with out writing a short book. Jun 12, 2017 · However, while Western sources of the time do recognize katana as a good sword, they do not support the image of katana's superiority over well-made Western swords. The Evolution of Japanese Armour An article by Boris Petrov Bedrosov, with illustrations by Jean Thibodeau Samurai: A man of honor, walking his way with a sword in hand; a determined warrior, showing no fear and pain; a ruthless soldier, giving no quarter and not asking it. ADVANTAGES – their whole body was very well protected by their metal armour – because of their armour it was easy to identify certain knights from certain places – a knight used many strong, large weapons and they also used a shield The Japanese katana was typically built with better quality, Nope. A famous blacksmith is testing a katana vs a german longsword. It was proven on youtube that a Japaneese Katana was more effective in piercing steel armour The katana had a hard edge and a soft spine and was made to be a good cutter and slicer. Single vs two-handed use[edit]. Aug 17, 2012 · Yeah, in general the Samurai wore less armor. A katana can't Knight vs Samurai: What Are The Differences Between Them? 1. In science  12 Dec 2019 Sword blades would always shatter on impact with plate armor and ten So European swords faced lots of tough metal armour, and there was a sort Japanese swords compared to their own stamped mass-produced junk  Katana (刀) is the word for " sword" in the Japanese language. wielding swords against opponents fully-equipped as 15th-century European knights. A Knights Sword Arming swords and Longswords When most people think of a knights sword, they usually imagine a warrior clad from head to toe in plate armor clashing with sword and shield against a similarly armored opponent. I'm not sure *WHAT* a Samurai would do against European armor: maybe take an arm or a leg at a joint? A katana *WILL* cut through metal a couple of times then it will be damaged beyond repair. European Knight vs. Has a comparison been made of the qualities of Samurai (Tamahagane), Damascus and Toledo steel (rather than the swords)? I've seen claims for each being better than the others. The Katana sliced by the blade continuously sliding across the surface while the European sword would just go straight through it since the blade is flat. Nov 04, 2007 · European knights were just as well trained and in most cases more well trained than the common samurai, and they faced a variety of different opponenets who all wielded different weaopns and wore different armors. They are two of the world's most recognizable and iconic weapons in history: the European double-handed knightly sword and the feudal Japanese double-handed samurai sword. Jul 08, 2011 · European knight wins, the samurai used swords designed more for slashing, against a knight in steel plate armour that is almost useless, tests have been done on samurai swords vs English long Exactly. Feb 10, 2013 · Kabutowari Helmet-Splitting Here we have a 500 year old helmet that was placed at the optimum height on a rigid surface and was cut by a master swordsman wielding a katana that was specifically made for the task using a technique that would never have been employed in battle (i. Japanese Samurai. European armor you have if you want to make any claims regarding it. There is so much more to be discussed, and this is certainly not meant to weigh in on the katana vs. European Knight Vs Japanese Samurai. Jul 07, 2019 · Japanese armor was light and supple, designed for deflecting a katana or arrow. Samurai uses a Katana and bow. The Best Katana – Authentic Katanas. Nov 26, 2019 · The katana makes a bigger dent in the armor with the same slashing motion but it does not go through. This is the reason the sword, in Europe, was the weapon of last resort when extremely close range combat could not be avoided. The armor of the Samurai is good armor but no were the level of that in Europe. A thrusting motion with the sword’s pointy end penetrates the armor a good half inch. In contrast european swords were more varied, you had short swords, rapiers, long swords, and greatswords as the most well known types and multiple countries putting out their versions of them. Swords built specifically to handle the rigors of test cutting and practice. In questa tavola si mettono a confronto le impugnature isolate nel trattato. Not sure if mentioned but the big issue with katana's vs european style swords is largely the crossguard and the typical length. Swords have evolved within certain civilizations, and timezones, to fullfill a purpose in those specific circumstances. Each katana blade is outfitted with different furniture or katana fittings. Katana vs European Longsword Longswords were blunter than you would imagine with the advent of armor slicing became less of a priority over just generally beating Feb 26, 2014 · Furthermore, the tight compressing of the chest caused by the armor and the low ventilation caused by the helmet made breathing much more difficult. The European longsword was good for thrusting but terrible in comparison at hacking. Samurai vs European Knight Open Discussions. In this contest, the Longswords won 3-1. Apr 14, 2008 · You got to see unlike the Katana; European swords are made to go against soft and hard armor, but there are no sword in the world that can cut through steel or even iron armor; or even shields! European swords can deliver good powerful thrust attacks; also much easier to thrust at weak parts of any armor out there. Every video I have watched that tries to compare the Japanese Katana to Medieval European Longsword miss the most significant thing to Oct 30, 2015 · How does Samurai Armor from the Iron Mountain Armory stand up to actual combat? Against the katana, yari, yumi, ju-jitsu, and real weapons used by samurai? Japanese Katana VS European Apr 14, 2008 · Katana vs. Jul 12, 2016 · A curved sword would hardly do any damage if a soldier were wearing chain-mail armor (which was a very popular form of armor in Western cultures). Another variant was the specialized armour-piercing swords of the estoc type. they are not slashing through a fully armored samurai’s steel plated armor either. No hand - no fight. If it's on topic, I'm also interested to know how they compare against modern steel. Naeshi (no Or maybe these monks had contact with Europeans? The Bar . Feudal Japanese samurais and medieval European knights never met on the battlefield, but it is interesting to ponder the outcome of such an encounter. This is why European swords evolved as they did – because armor evolved. and was overall more versatile than its European counterpart. Apr 14, 2008 · You can stab through chain mail. Jul 08, 2011 · Japanese Samurai vs European Knight? I know this gets asked allot on here but who do you think would win. First we’ll take a look at the European Knight in Full Armor. They were meant to make a display of status and privilege, and when used for battle, they existed to strike swift and decisive blows against foes in lacquered armor who fought primarily without shields. The reason being a katana, although sharp, were designed were there was no metal armor. I saw the rapier idea but I was under the impression that the rapier is a one handed sword and I would think a comparable sword would have to be a two hand capable sword. European long swords are predominately thrusting weapons developed as a sort of armor peircer to be used against European style plate armor and chain mail. But the katana isn't very good at all at stabbing. Si trova indicata la catalogazione, il numero di istanze rappresentato anche dalla dimensione in scala logaritmica, l'impiego dell'impugnatura in ordine decrescente, le connessioni dirette che evidenziano i legami tra impungature con differenze minime dovute agli angoli della spada o del rapporto polso/spada ed… Cutting Swords. Many assume Samurai were imposingly tall and broad, but their armor and weaponry merely makes them seem that way  Even though their armor isn't strong as the knight's, the Katana can just slice through the Not to mention Europeans were decently larger build than Japanese. Rapier: Another Fantasy Worth Considering. However, the chainsaw does much more damage to objects (like cars) than the katana. However, from the earliest days, armor almost always had more than one layer. Both from the 1500's. I think the better sword would go to the Samurai, yet in weapon diversity and armor the Medieval Europeans should win. We carry the entire line of Paul Chen Hanwei Samurai swords, Chinese swords and their entire medieval swords and armor line. There is typically a view that the katana and rapier represent the ideal cutting blade and the ideal thrusting blade; the "highest" development of East and West. The Japanese katana was typically built with better quality, Nope. Knights beat other knights using very specific sword techniques that the katana simply isn't designed to perform because samurai were not trained to deal with a knight's armor. the best vs the best were pretty even. Samurai armor is not lighter then European Armor, in fact it is about the same! Also a Samurai is not going to be more maneuverable then a knight. What Is The Knight? In fact, a Knight is an individual awarded a knighthood honorary title by a monarch or other political chief for an obligation to the monarch or nation, particularly in the military capacity. Oh, and Direwolf - try to post a link to any tests of Katana Vs. He made both weapons exactly in the same way like they were made in the past. . Japanese Katana VS European Longsword - Samurai sword VS Knight Broadsword by kinsei1560 / Japanese Katana VS European Longsword - Samurai sword VS Knight Broadsword. ;) ps: Full Metal Jacket was fun to watch, but this is incredible, it was Sep 20, 2015 · Viking Sword, Katana and khukuri vs Gambeson or Cloth Armor! Sword and Spear Vs Gambeson, Padded or Cloth Armor Test! European Longsword VS Japanese Katana - End All Comparison! Jan 20, 2017 · The ultimate KATANA vs LONGSWORD analysis Shadiversity. A 10-9 round for the katana. #1: Armor, What are they all using? #2: Skill, I’m going to assume that they are all = in skill. Neither a european Longsword nor a Katana would be able to cut through plate Armor, thats a simple fact because they had around 20 to 50 HRC. 23 May 2019 Standard Jitte vs. It was meant to kill as quickly as possible. The soft spine did not allow it to flex like European swords that were spring tempered. someone might write: “The katana samurai sword is the best fighting sword in history. ) I'm sure it's not  12 Aug 2019 Have you ever wondered if a katana can cut through plate armour? There might be some misconceptions about katanas you aren't aware of. A katana is essentially a big two handed sabre, so very similar to cavalry swords which work best against unarmed opponents since the shape does allow a much better slash and pull motion much like one finds chef's knife. The Katana is a type of single-edged longsword indigenous to Japan. That's a negative, Ghost Rider. Katanas are not only the worst weapon in the game, but they can only be used by two classes, and even then only to counter, assuming you figure The Katana is very effective, but needs high presicion to deliver lethal blows. Conclusion The katana wins. Bring a katana to europe and you would get butchered trying to find opponents with low armor. I go with the Samurai. Katana Vs unarmed peasant/bound POW/Criminal etc = Excellent Katana Vs light armour (leather/fabric/thin laminated wood/V thin metal) = Medium results. Indeed, full European plate armor with maile might very well damage the keen edge on particularly fine katanas. Quite the opposite of what they'd have you believe, really. AikiWeb's principal purpose is to serve the Internet community as a repository and dissemination point for aikido information. Gone were large battles with armored combatants. 16 Sep 2019 Class: Medieval 1 Obtaining; 2 Analysis; 3 Longsword vs. And European armor in contrast to Samurai armor had a higher level of focus on endurance. Articulated plate armor was lighter than mail and the wearer could move as well or better than the wearer of Japanese heavy armor. The first layer would be a pair of loose breaches (see picture on next page) and a shirt. Medieval and Renaissance historical weapons and armor replicas of the highest we will work with you to create the sword or other weapon of your dreams. So later on European swords of different Types were more advanced for the task they had to do when in Japan there was nearly no change in warfware. Even if the bullet is 1/10th the weight and 100 times the speed of the sword then the formula ( Energy(kinetic)= Mass x Velocity^2 ) applies. other sword but by the time the katana was introduced, armor was made of iron or steel. The best katana in my mind are the ones made hundreds of years ago, the Nihonto (日本刀, nihontō) blades, which means a ‘Japanese sword made in Japan by a Japanese swordsmith under the original forging methods’. By John Clements, ARMA Director. Nov 30, 2012 · Both now have heavy-duty armor, but by now the Samurai are still behind on the shear protectiveness of European armor-patterns. If you want to cut through steel armor (or another sword), you would need a very thin, unbreakable line for the edge. How would a typical hand and a half sword compare to a Katana. I really have no idea how one would beat the other one using swords and bows but somebody would The arms and armor used by knights and other Western European fighting men changed a lot during the Middle Ages. As will it often have more weak spots then European Armor, and were a knight will love to thrust the sword or halberd at. European sword on the other hand. Sep 23, 2017 · Rapier VS Katana. The trend during the shogunate was the duel-- one on one, no armor, with swords. Our line of Japanese weapons and armor encompass traditional and modern methods to create a wide range of items for the collector and martial artist alike. May 16, 2019 · Armor vs fast objects, the difference between a bullet and a sword is that the bullet is likely moving at 1800 feet per second while the sword is travelling at 18 feet per second. Re: Japanese Katana VS European Longsword - Samurai sword VS Knight Broadsword Besides the person I would go with almost any European sword. By John Clements. Japanese Katana vs European Katana were primarily sidearms for samurai, who were primarily archers until the late 16th century. European knights are What are the point of katanas? (Vs. European Knights in the 13th century and before only wore mail, but they wore thick coats of it. One including their solidier or their warriors, those who fought for their country. japanese sword. Plate armour is a historical type of personal body armour made from iron or steel plates, culminating in the iconic suit of armour entirely encasing the wearer. He even imported iron ore from japan for the katana to use the same material. Of course, I am only scratching the surface of such a deep topic. 101 results But the Knight's armor would deflect any blows from a katana and would eventually stab the Samuri when he gets tired. It's pretty well accepted that European plate was quite superior to the Japanese equivalent, if for no other reason than I don't think they are wearing armor since it would be a dumb fight if they were, Imagine two people hitting eachother with swords doing no damage and even then the European sword would have an advantage over the Katana since stabbing trough the gaps of the armor is actually an thing they did in the past and the Katana can stab as well but's harder to do beause of the tip. Samurai Armor vs Knights Plate Armor. I'm a newbie to swords and was wondering what would compare to the katana from the european side. Why did katanas have such small hand guards compared to European blades? 14 Apr 2008 He swears that the Katana could slice and thrust through every kind of European medieval armor(chainmail,plate mail, plate. And against a fully armored knight in 15th century armor, a katana would be a poor choice of armament, while a European long sword of the same era would fare more favorably against Japanese armor. katana vs european armor